Who Really Gives a Shit?
On page 14 of the new issue of Writer’s Digest, the mystery writer Morgan Hunt wonders aloud whether or not she should use foul language in her writing. I know this subject intimately. The most common criticism of Dad Gone Mad is…? No, not that I’m a t-shirt whore. And no, not that the “Recently” links on the left sidebar are busted. It’s that the language used here is “salty” and “scatological”. I therefore wondered if Ms. Hunt might have an argument I could use in my own defense.
(Wow. A whore AND a thief. Mom must be so proud.)
Ms. Hunt claims to ask herself three questions when facing the decision to have a character use a profanity:
1) Does it work for the reader?
2) Does it work for the character?
3) Does it abridge my integrity?
I felt compelled to turn these very mirrors on myself, if only for the exercise in self-deprecation and some good blog fodder.
I consider myself fortunate that I have long since eviscerated my own integrity, leaving only two criteria to examine. One point for me.
Does it work for the reader? For some, especially my sister, it works like Peaches and Herb. For my lawyer friend Brian, it’s poetry. But I can’t speak for the rest of you. I suppose if you’re here and you’re fucking reading this shit, you’re wise enough to see that the “salt” is entirely in context. If you can’t see that, you’re probably a douchebag cocksucker anyway, in which case you should be reading that blond Republican glory hound who hates Jews and gays and talks like someone with half a testicle.
Does it work for the character? Hard to answer. Are there characters here? Perhaps. And maybe my character is a guy who doesn’t know when to stop cursing. In that case, it completely works for the character. It IS the character.
I’m over-thinking this. Everybody just leave your favorite profanities in the comments. A vote for shit-eating cockmaster is a vote for FREEDOM!
